Chapter 2
PUBLICATIONS ARTICLES NOUNS
We have seen that Dr. Tinelli presents itself as a researcher. This call was reiterated in the Statute of CESAP, she created the Research Center, which gives the purpose " to act as a permanent observatory for the study and dissemination ” ecc. Sempre sul sito del CeSAP si legge inoltre l’impegnativo proposito di dare “ informazioni continuamente aggiornate ” a un ancor più impegnativo elenco di soggetti a cui queste “ informazioni continuamente aggiornate ” sono indirizzate:
- psicologi,
- sociologi,
- assistenti sociali,
- police,
- educators,
- teachers
- lawyers
- magistrates
- doctors,
- educators,
- operators psychosocial
- but especially abused
- and all those relatives, family, friendships, living ...
For those who work as a professional psychologist, act as reference for the victims of psychological abuse is natural. However, what is puzzling is the presence in the list of categories such as lawyers, judges, doctors etc.. It comes natural to suspect a propensity to be presumed. Well, to tell large. Such confidence in their own ability also has a second effect: it creates an expectation of the publications that we will now consider.
Before examining the work claimed by Dr. Tinelli in its curriculum scholar, remember that in science there are rules about how to publish research, studies, speeches, etc.. and how to relate to them. It is not surprising. If the game Ricochets has drawn up norms, even more regulation is needed much more important in the world of scientific research, which must be reduced to avoid a Babel of voices Wizards Oronzo. For this reason, references to a publication must contain clear all those details that will enable other scholars in the field to easily locate the text. The violation of this standard elementary result in the loss of credibility for the author and his work.
Un altro criterio riguarda l’autorevolezza della rivista su cui si pubblica, che deve essere scientifica. In un mondo dove anche gli articoli delle riviste più prestigiose vengono passati al microscopio, è intuitivo che quanto pubblicato su riviste non scientifiche non venga considerato (e vantare un articolo apparso sul Gazzettino di Rovigo susciterebbe ilarità). In pratica, scrivere uno studio e appenderlo al muro della camera da letto non vale.
Infine, gli articoli divulgativi o i testi di convegni e conferenze, pure questi divulgativi per loro natura, non valgono. Umberto Eco scrive su l’Espresso articoli interessanti, ma non sono lavori scientifici.
Veniamo quindi agli “ studies " the researcher Tinelli lists on its website www.loritatinelli.it and allowing it to set itself the ambitious goal to be a reference for lawyers, judges, sociologists, educators and the rest of company, as well as his fellow psychologists. Addressing the number of studies, research, articles and interviews (they are listed as well) that the work psychologist must have accumulated over the past ten years may be of concern. No fear: there are only 17 listed items. Few but good, you'd think, Dr. Tinelli have indicated only the most relevant work. It would be logical, but in this case would be particularly surprising. Better to postpone the evaluation until after we have examined the material.
The first item on the list is " THE SEVEN AND THE FAMILY " big games and bad: there is only the title without any bibliographic references. Just above we saw that the references are not an option to be accepted with gratitude, but an essential element (otherwise someone might be tempted to pass off the argument and " essay " to studies published by two universities). As reference list is important, you can tell by the fact that must comply with strict rules dictated by the reference categories. A psychologist will then follow the conventions established by the APA, the American Psychological Association, which require this structure:
- [author]
not all. The information from APA, the rules vary depending on whether you are quoting in the text or bibliography, which cites an article or a thesis, etc.. They are basic things and knowing them is enough to read the funny manual for students, "How do a thesis" by Umberto Eco.
Returning to "study" THE SEVEN AND THE FAMILY , the lack of references to publication damages the credibility of the entire curriculum. But we are not Tignosi how researchers (true) and there is no formalized. Also because previously we have seen worse. There is informal but we will do well to be wary, because the researcher, who in his site even transcribes the text of a banal interview on vandalism issued to the unknown " Gazzettino-Nuts, a monthly city life " , this interview contains references, while the far more important (apparently) " THE SEVEN AND THE FAMILY " spreads an aura of mystery. A reticence that makes no sense.
Fortunately, the magic of the search engine comes in handy and surprisingly we find that this contribution to scientific progress really has been published. But not on paper, but on the site of CESAP. Not bad, the product of his studies lead researcher Tinelli if the public her on her website and then lists it in its curriculum. Ingenious. But at this point would have been better Gazzettino di Rovigo, or at least the " Noci-Gazzettino " (which, as we shall see shortly, is not even called that).
The second work is " PSYCHOLOGICAL ABUSE AND MENTAL CONTROL . Although approximate, the references here are: Leadership Medica, No. 6, 2000. As a scientific journal is not much, but at least there really thereof was published. Perhaps because it remains the only a finire sulla carta, e si sa che i figli unici godono di particolare riguardo, per sicurezza la dr.ssa Tinelli lo elenca due volte. Nella pagina “Articoli” e nella pagina “Pubblicazioni” (1).
“ EFFETTI DELL'ADESIONE AI TESTIMONI DI GEOVA SUI MINORI ”. Ci risiamo, ma dovremo farci l’abitudine: anche qui mancano i riferimenti bibliografici. Nuovamente Google fa il delatore e così scopriamo che anche questo “articolo” (anche lui del lontano 1999) ha trovato ospitalità unicamente sul sito della ricercatrice a cui dovrebbero rivolgersi magistrati, avvocati, & C. The above
for " effects of the accession ... "also applies to
- DIAGNOSIS ETA 'EVOLUTION, the 1998 pro manoscipto
- THE PARENTAL ALIENATION SYNDROME AS A TOOL OF THE SEVEN PRIVILEGED
With these two articles will reach the paradox. The first, " DIAGNOSIS ETA 'EVOLUTIONARY ", not visible on the site of CESAP. This means that Tinelli the curriculum mentions in his article that was published on its website-only curriculum. It looks like a pun, but the substance is boasting a publication that does not really exist. The second article but it hung at his "table", but if the others had criticized the lack of references, this is even changed the title from " THE PARENTAL ALIENATION SYNDROME AS A TOOL OF THE SEVEN PRIVILEGED "to a more expeditious " parental alienation syndrome ".
"new religiosity THE 'ON THE THRESHOLD OF THIRD MILLENNIUM "Here's the reference:" Paper presented eponymous course information Ce.SAP in November 1999. " Series anything goes. Place in a curriculum to the report shown in a joint conference (ie not organized from an institution of great prestige) is an obvious anomaly is convenient to show that no one is scraping the barrel. But Tinelli not throw anything away and heading " Articles " insert a report that was not even a conference, but for a " course information " . For more CESAP held by, association with headquarters in his living room. We are at symbolic play (2) with which children pretend to be a different reality: "We that I was the princess and you ... .
" MEMBERSHIP TO THE GROUP OF JEHOVAH'S WITNESSES: HOW AND WHY . Still " text of a conference , yet far back as 1999, but which conference is not known. There is an interesting detail that catches your eye when reading the text of this pseudo-study that begins:
- " In recent years we are witnessing in Western countries, the proliferation of new forms of worship. Even in Catholic Italy, they are rapidly increasing. " (see here )
and compare it with the text of " THE new religiosity ' " , we saw just above, and that starts with:
- " In recent years there has been assisting in Western countries, the proliferation of new forms of worship. Even in Catholic Italy, they are rapidly increasing. " (see here )
" SUFFERED AFFILIATION: the sectarian communities and the rights of children " . It is the third report for the symposium included the "Articles". In the movie "My friends", the director Monicelli wondered what it was genius. In this work of Dr. Tinelli perhaps find the answer. To give authority to a treaty, is used to cite the works of other authors, confirming what has been exposed or has been taken for granted. In this report, the places below for reference Tinelli " EFFECTS OF THE ACCESSION TO THE JEHOVAH'S WITNESSES ON CHILDREN, by Lorita Tinelli, Pro Manoscripto, 1999 ", which is the" article "we saw a little earlier," released "on his website. What tenderness, with two drawing pins put up an "article" to the table in his bedroom, then cites a report for a conference held on his bed. Even here, however we are always 1999, the year mirabilis.
" mass suicide: the search for absolute truth " This is a gem. Finally, a search that really saw the dedication of the publication on paper: the number of onset of the journal Labyris in 2000. What gives a touching effect Tartarin of Tarascon is that Labyris is the journal of the Association who has an office in his living room and is published in his living room in his free time between the conferences held on the bed in her bedroom. A curiosity: Labyris boasted no less than (and unnamed anonymous), who liaises with the corresponding " EU and non EU countries " .
by Labyris, No. 3 / 4, 2000 As befits the games of childhood, the magazine was short-lived life, just 5 times. Although this contribution to science, Tartarini Walnut lists it twice for safety, and being so loved by the author is worth giving a look . Inspired by " news of yet another tragic mass suicide" occurred "in Kampala, Uganda, on 18 March. " In fact, the massacre took place March 17 and 18, in Kanungu and Kampala, which is 400 km from Kanungu. These two errors followed by a list the previous cases, followed by the list of terms that have followed that of "brainwashing", and concludes with an explanation of the mass suicides according to the theories of psychiatrist Viktor Frankl. In practice, it is not an article but a commentary on the news-style "Did you know that" the Enigmistica week. No wonder it has been published only by his magazine.
" DISCOMFORT IN THE PRE-ADOLESCENCE: RESULTS OF AN EXPERIMENTAL " . This alleged article we saw in the first chapter, it is the thesis of the course in graphology, that in 2000 the Institute G. Moretti has published in his magazine writing. But this is not a virtue: the institute publishes all of his final thesis course in graphology. Although this paper is reported twice, both among the "Articles" that in the "Publications" (adding that the quote on the "Curriculum" are 3 times).
" Scribble TO DESIGN BY: REVIEW OF 'THE CHILD IN HIS EVOLUTION GRAPHICS . of this item is impossible to know only the year 2000. There is another, even the text. As for Google insists treacherously to say that he knows nothing, the slothful. Once again, the researcher has Tinelli a study that has not even posted on the bedside table of her room.
PUBLICATIONS
Now to the Publications page, where we mentioned: " Young: Mirror of the adult world ", "Liberty or free plagiarism? " " unusual experiences defined parapsychology ", published in late 2000 in the journal " Gazzettino-Nuts, a monthly city life ". The first thing to say is that " Noci-Gazzettino " not exist, the real name of the magazine is nuts gazette, without the hyphen, and the subtitle is not " Monthly of city life to " but Magazine city life (see here ). Apart from the obvious fact that Nuts Gazzettino is not a scientific journal, it is a period of poor relief, does not have even one of his website. Whereas Noci is a small town of 19,500 inhabitants, the publication of a gazette article on nuts is a glory to be commemorated at the bar with friends jokingly. See it included in the "Publications" that should a scholar credited as belonging to the world of scientific research, puzzled. A boast which follows that of Tartarin tarasconesi and his friends. Moreover, it is hard to believe that " unusual experiences defined parapsychology " is a publication by Tinelli: as the name of a conference, it seems more likely to be the title of a paragraph which " Noci-Gazzettino " he gave the news. It remains to say that the conference (organized by CESAP) has left no trace on the network. Fate shared by the three publications.
Now that we see these three (unavailable) published articles about the pseudo-Gazzettino nuts, it also ends the discussion of the item curriculum " writes for newspapers and periodicals " , we met in the first chapter and had been left open. The journals are: the now defunct magazine Labirys, an unknown monthly in a country of 19,500 inhabitants and the Medical Leadership magazine in 2000 that the published article. There is no trace of the newspapers. Difficult not to use the term swagger.
who had the patience to resist so far, now see his perseverance rewarded with a surprise: two misunderstandings or, more precisely, two distortions. In short, we understood, a couple of whoppers. They are:
- I took the neck by a chain , Booklet prepared for the traveling exhibition on
'esotericism promoted by CESAP (2003); - Truth Perhaps you seek from me you can find ,
brochure prepared for the traveling exhibition organized by sull'esoterismo CESAP (2003).
honor that can fly over to the signature on a " Brochure " . The surprise announcement that the show has not been " promoted by CESAP " , but conceived, organized, financed and organized dall'ARIS Veneto that has full ownership. Official documents of the exhibition, the name of Tartarini Walnut figure tra i sette collaboratori (nel suo caso per aver “ svolto attività di relatrice e di supporto ”) e viene dopo quello dei due co-organizzatori: la curatrice della mostra Silvana Radoani e il Comune di Venezia. Per aver collaborato, la dr.ssa Tinelli si attribuisce il merito dell’iniziativa.
Relazione conclusiva della mostra, su carta intestata ARIS Veneto. 
Segnalibro, un gadget della mostra. In evidenza il logo dell’ARIS Veneto;
il logo del CeSAP non compare.
Svelata la sorpresa, vale la pena dare uno sguardo a questi due opuscoli annoverati come “Pubblicazioni”, perché ricchi di aspetti farseschi.
Il primo, il cui vero titolo è “ Presi al collo da una catena. Analisi di una superstizione diffusa ”, tratta delle cosiddette Catene di Sant’Antonio. Viene presentato come una “analisi”, nella realtà è appena un esercizio di banale bricolage che non richiede alcuna competenza. Tra le 49 pagine che lo compongono c’è un solo articolo, l’Introduzione, che è di 3 pagine, però firmate da Maurizio Antonello dell’ARIS Veneto. Le pagine restanti riportano:
- il testo di undici “Catene”;
- un’intervista a Paolo Attivissimo copia-incollata da Internet;
- 9 articoli di quotidiani;
- i “Suggerimenti utili”, ancora di Paolo Attivissimo.
By this yardstick, we might include in the curriculum Figurine Panini collections made by children.
The second brochure about the charlatans: magicians, fortune tellers and psychics different. Essentially the same considerations made for the brochure above, except that here the end result is worse. The formula is the same as before, namely a collection of materials readily available on the Internet. There is an article by John Panunzio, copied from the site of Antiplagio Phone, which is only two-thirds of the booklet. In the remaining pages are some commercials so-called wizards.
To tie the exhibition of advertising texts, the author inserts his comments (of derision), but as the brochure had previous stringatissimi, here dwells a bit ', showing a surprisingly hesitant Italian, which sometimes cover up to ridiculous
- can not distinguish between sponsors and slogan: " His sponsor is 'Give me your hand, I'll tell you who you are' " ;
- inserisce considerazioni ironiche di una banalità imbarazzante: “ Beh solo 36 ore non sono mica male per risolvere completamente la propria crisi sentimentale!!! ” ;
- fa un uso sfiancante di punti esclamativi a fini enfatici, 8 in un brano di appena 13 parole: “ Beh! È di sicuro un’offerta da non perdere!!!! Half of his salary! ";
- cram every page of demeaning commentaries invariably accented with unnecessary exclamation points:
- (well this information as very important date, does not seem to add much to its credibility ... but imagine that his father was very famous in some time, somewhere!)
- (Do not know which one! Nda)
- The important thing is to be convinced!
- (upper case is his! Nda)
- (who?? NDA),
- (and with so many issues that we believe it is essential! NDA)
Gli errori e le noiose battutine ironiche rendono i commenti dell’autrice inadatti ad un testo divulgativo e più in linea con le banalità che sentiamo dal salumiere. L’opuscolo si chiude col capitolo “ Conclusione ” , costituito dall’ennesimo copia e incolla (le istruzioni per eventuali segnalazioni al Garante). Queste istruzioni vengono introdotte da una frase, piuttosto contorta, contenente una raccapricciante virgola tra soggetto ( esperti del mondo magico ) e verbo ( fanno ), che vale la pena vedere coi propri occhi:
Now we come to the center piece of wooden medals, the book:
- Techniques of persuasion among the Jehovah's Witnesses , Libreria Editrice Vaticana, Vatican City, 1998, pag.324
Finally we should not talk about bragging or passes for junk jewelry. This is just a book and - coincidence - in this case also shows the references. And he scritto proprio la dr.ssa Tinelli. La qualità espositiva, dei contenuti e grammaticale non lasciano dubbi.
Innanzitutto chiariamo che si tratta della tesi di laurea a cui è stato cambiato il titolo. Il che attesta l’abilità della ricercatrice barese che riesce a moltiplicare un singolo lavoro in 3 onorificenze: la laurea universitaria per la quale il testo è stato scritto, un fantomatico “ studio ” pubblicato dal “Dipartimento di Psicologia [...] Università La Sapienza di Roma, 1996 ” e infine un libro. I complimenti sono d’obbligo.
begin by specifying that the pages are 312 and not 324. Venial sin, but the bad habit of stretching the fish is a temptation not resist. Let us examine these 312 pages. Of presentation, preface, acknowledgments, introduction, interviews and contact details of respondents, classifications, methods of analysis and various amenities they go 32 pages. Following is the transcript of the testimony of some former followers and Jehovah's Witnesses, identified as "Gino", "Paul" and so on until page 108. On completion of the interminable introduction, seems to have finally begin the discussion of the techniques of persuasion. To give this impression is the title of the chapters: " How to become a JW "," The JW and the family ", " Group life "," The JW and the company ", but now the disappointment has become resignation after them fly away with Gino and his brothers have gone another 120 pages containing excerpts from magazines such as Awake! and The Watchtower. There are 120 pages full of lists and pervasive references (which are missing in his resume). Here the contribution of research to the National President is limited to short presentations of connection between a citation the other, and the "study" shows itself for what it is in reality a sort of "Bignami" on JW. We are so
on page 229. Finally starts the study itself, with chapters dedicated to observation of the studied phenomenon, which ends on page 248. They are 20 (twenty) pages, which is followed by the chapter "Conclusions" (pages 249 and 250). With this, the thesis became a " study by the Department of Psychology " and then the book " Techniques of persuasion and so on. " ended. Unless si voglia elevare a ricerca scientifica il glossario, la bibliografia e una cinquantina di pagine che riportano moduli e circolari ad uso interno del gruppo, calendari di eventi e programmi delle adunanze, che con sprezzo del ridicolo vengono definiti “ documenti riservati ” .
Mi auguro che il lettore apprezzi la cortesia di avergli risparmiato la disamina delle 20 pagine che costituiscono il contributo della dr.ssa Tinelli al libro. È che ritengo che l’antifona sia ormai chiara, ma su richiesta posso dedicargli un paragrafo.
Ultima considerazione in merito al libro. È risaputo che quando gli editori si mostrano insensibili al valore dell’arte o al progresso scientifico, pagando è possibile sopperire a questa ottusa miopia - e al contempo mettere in bella mostra nel salotto di casa un libro col proprio nome in copertina (e stipare lo sgabuzzino con le copie restanti). Non sappiamo come siano andate le cose, c’è però una pagina nel sito www.loritatinelli.it dove si legge una nota molto interessante in merito: “ Se si desidera acquistare una o più copie scrivere all'autrice ” ecc. Sono trascorsi undici anni, ma ci sono ancora copie del libro che tengono compagnia ai barattoli di piselli.
Una curiosità: poco sopra le istruzioni per l’acquisto, si può leggere una inattesa recensione al libro, favorevole benché lo definisca desueto, firmata dal dr. Enrico Girone. Se non è un caso di omonimia, allora è il dr. Enrico Girone che nella pagina contenente lo statuto del CeSAP figura come uno dei soci fondatori dell’associazione.
Siamo arrivati al bilancio finale. A parte un trascurabile articolo pubblicato su Leadership Medica nel 2000, e un ancor più trascurabile libro uscito nel 1998 e custodito nello sgabuzzino, tutto il resto è una processione di illusioni:
- la tesi di laurea e la “tesina” of being falsely passed off as an unknown publications
- articles published on anonymity gazette nuts (of which crippled the name);
- only research published on the website of his association and studies that even she has published;
- reports unknown conferences elevated to the rank of articles.
Almost everything before 2000, prior to the drafting of the proclamation seen early on " itself as a permanent observatory for lo studio e la divulgazione ” ecc. Il grado di attendibilità della ricercatrice auto nominatasi “giornalista” e Presidente Nazionale risalta impietoso. Il non aver prodotto in tutti questi dieci anni neanche uno studio o una ricerca, per un Centro Studi che “ si propone di offrire informazioni continuamente aggiornate ” , fa considerare la qualifica di Centro Studi l’ennesima infondata vanteria al pari dell’iscrizione all’Ordine dei Giornalisti.
Nel capitolo “Conclusioni” del suo libro si legge:
- “ Spesso è la nostra parte emotional, and more primitive, that helps you make decisions that sometimes prove wrong. "
The sentence makes no sense. It is the order of things that a decision can be weighted in the long wrong, if " sometimes prove wrong " even those taken by "our side emotional " , then nothing changes: the emotion is that the cold rationality " sometimes mistaken " . Blunders of logic aside, it is probably an invitation not to take decisions dictated by emotions. It is a suggestion that Dr. Lorita Tinelli should not only preach to others, while writing nonsense like " Posizioning " (3) (instead of positioning), or enters treacherous comma between subject and verb.
Notes:
- Anyone interested in knowing the value part can be found here , having read about a third, in good conscience believe that I have already given.
- In Developmental Psychology, Gioco Simbolico è il gioco di finzione in cui il bambino negozia un’organizzazione concordata di attori, co-attori, registi e pubblico. Così un oggetto viene usato al posto di un altro e la persona si comporta come se fosse un’altra (“Facciamo che ero….”).
- Pagina 7 del libro “Tecniche di persuasione tra i Testimoni di Geova”.
0 comments:
Post a Comment